CYI Worldwide
  • GOD
    • God's Love Letter To You
    • Does GOD Exist?
    • This Was Your Life
    • Find God
  • Q&A
  • Prophecy
  • COMIC BOOKS
  • Get HELP
    • Speak To A Counselor
    • Bullying Sucks!
    • Depression
    • ADHD
    • Encouragement
    • Fighters
  • Exposed
  • Podcasts
  • Sex
  • Evangelism

       NEWS WATCH

EXPOSED! Pop Culture Lies

‘Kids for Cash’ and ‘The Injustice System’

9/1/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
Source: The NY Times
By ABBE SMITH

As we commemorate the 50th anniversary of Gideon v. Wainwright, the landmark Supreme Court decision that gave poor defendants the right to counsel, it would be nice to celebrate. That case, taken together with the 1967 decision In re Gault, which gave juveniles the same rights in court as adults, stands for the principle that process matters in our system of justice; when faced with the awesome power of the state, the accused — rich or poor, old or young — must be properly armed.

Two recent books put a damper on the celebration, revealing just how random and impoverished justice can be, and how flimsy the right to counsel. In “Kids for Cash,” the investigative reporter William Ecenbarger tells the story behind a corruption scandal so brazen and cruel it defies imagination. Between 2003 and 2008, two Pennsylvania judges accepted millions of dollars in kickbacks from a private juvenile detention facility in exchange for sending children — girls and boys, some as young as 11 — to jail.

Picture
It is a harrowing tale, lucidly told by a journalist with a good eye for detail. The children’s stories continue to unsettle long after the book ends: the 13-year-old incarcerated forthrowing a piece of steak at his mother’s boyfriend; the 15-year-old for throwing a sandal at her mother; the 11-year-old for calling the police after his mother locked him out of the house; the 14-year-old for writing a satirical Myspace profile. Another 14-year-old, an A student, was sentenced for writing “Vote for Michael Jackson” on a few stop signs; she had a seizure while in detention, banging her head so hard she cracked her dental braces.

Mark Ciavarella is the judge who sent away all those children — and several thousand others — in cahoots with Judge Michael Conahan. Ecenbarger calls what took place “a routine and systematic form of child abuse.” After the briefest of hearings — the average length was four minutes — kids were dispatched to detention centers in which the judges had a financial interest. If parents were unable to pay the costs of detention, their children were sometimes held longer. One teenager’s Social Security survivor’s check, from his father’s death, was garnished to pay the costs.

What happened in Luzerne County, formerly known for coal and now for organized crime and public corruption (in certain districts, teachers have to pay for teaching jobs), was not a case of rogue judges acting alone. In a “festival of injustice,” prosecutors, public defenders, teachers and court employees saw it all and did nothing. At Ciavarella’s direction, juvenile probation officers talked kids out of exercising their right to counsel.

There are some heroes: local reporters who broke the story; a whistle-blowing family court judge; Juvenile Law Center attorneys who represented two of the detained children and petitioned the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to stop the widespread waiver of counsel; parents who did everything they could to fight for their kids. There is some vindication: Ciavarella and Conahan are serving lengthy prison terms, and the children’s records have been expunged. But there is no happy ending. Many children were traumatized by being shackled and summarily shipped off to jail only to be shunned by friends when they were ­released. Seven years after his incarceration, the young man accused of steak-throwing (he denied the charge) still has “a lost look about him,” Ecenbarger writes, “as though he has been permanently startled.”

In “The Injustice System,” the lawyer and writer Clive Stafford Smith (author of the excellent “Eight O’Clock Ferry to the Windward Side: Seeking Justice in Guantánamo Bay”) makes a strong case that Krishna Maharaj, a British man sentenced to death for a double murder in Miami 26 years ago, is innocent. Smith (no relation) took up the case after Maharaj had been on death row for seven years and succeeded in getting the death sentence thrown out. Ironically, this may have hurt his client’s fight: prisoners who merely die in prison don’t receive the attention or resources of those on death row.

Maharaj is now 74 and in a wheelchair. He recently filed a post-conviction challenge based on newly discovered evidence, which the State of Florida is contesting. Previous appeals have been rejected. If Maharaj is turned away from the courts once more, his hope will lie with the governor of Florida.

The book is a complicated whodunit, with the likely perpetrators still at large or dead. The murder victims, a father and son who were apparently involved in nefarious, lucrative activities, some connected to Colombian drug cartels, knew plenty of people who might have wanted to kill them. Maharaj’s supposed motive — resentment over the breakup of a business partnership and wounded vanity over an unflattering newspaper portrayal — is convoluted by comparison. In the course of recounting the crime, trial and appeals, Smith paints a bleak picture of criminal justice in America — this is Miami, after all, not some backwater town. There are dishonest cops, smug prosecutors, a feckless defense lawyer (now a judge) and venal witnesses.

Although Maharaj was once wealthy and well traveled — he was an importer of exotic fruit — he had no idea what he was in for when he was arrested. He spent little on a lawyer because he believed a jury would easily see he wasn’t guilty. Maharaj remains bewildered by a system that seems to care more about finality than anything else. One judge forbade his lawyer to even mention the word “innocent.”

Notwithstanding the book’s unfortunate title, which suggests a polemic, “The Injustice System” is really a love story — a moving tale of devotion by an extraordinary lawyer who nearly bankrupts himself and his fledgling public-­interest law office to fight for his client’s life and liberty. Smith is at his best when he shares small stories — his first visit with Maharaj; his talks with Maharaj’s wife, Marita, who has stood by her husband all these years; his visit with Maharaj when he was shackled to a hospital bed after surgery for a flesh-eating disease contracted in prison — and his own feelings of despair. Sometimes the book gets lost in detail and reads too much like a brief. It is not always easy to be both a storyteller and an advocate.

“Kids for Cash” and “The Injustice System” reveal the deep gap between cherished ideals and harsh reality in a country addicted to incarceration. A majority of the children in Luzerne County who did time had no legal counsel. Krishna Maharaj no longer has a right to counsel; he has a great lawyer by sheer luck. But, a half-­century after Gideon, justice in this country is not supposed to depend on something as capricious as luck.



Abbe Smith, a law professor at Georgetown University, is the author of “Case of a Lifetime: A Criminal Defense Lawyer’s Story.” Her next book, “How Can You Represent Those People?,” will be published this summer.




A version of this review appears in print on March 31, 2013, on page BR21 of the Sunday Book Review with the headline: Undue Process.

0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Get News Updates!  

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Subscribe in a reader

    Categories

    All
    2 Timothy 3
    501c3
    911
    Abortion
    Alcohol
    Aliens UFO
    Aliens - UFO
    America Destruction
    America Destruction
    Anti Semitism
    Anti-Semitism
    Apologetics
    Apostacy
    Atheism
    Atheist Church
    Attack On Family
    Bible
    Border Wars
    Bullying
    Catholicism
    Censorship]
    Chicago Terror Zone
    Chrislam
    Christian Persecution
    Christian Persecution
    Christian Values
    Chris White
    Church Decline
    Church Issues
    Church Nonsense
    Climate Change
    College
    Culture Of Death
    Cutting Edge Ministries
    Cutting-edge-ministries
    Damascus
    Debate
    Destruction Of America
    Destruction-of-america
    Deviant Sexuality
    Drugs
    Ecumenical Movement
    Elite
    Emergent Church
    End Times
    End-times
    Evangelism
    Evolution
    Extreme Christianity
    False Flag
    False Gospels
    False Gospels
    Farming
    FEMA Camp
    Feminism
    Feminization Of Men
    Free Speech
    Gangs
    Gay
    Gay Agenda
    Gender Identity
    Global Warming
    Global-warming
    GMO
    Good News
    Government Corruption
    Grace
    Grok Radio
    Hate Groups
    Health News
    Heaven
    Hollywood Exposed
    Hollywood Exposed
    Homeless
    Homeschooling
    Homosexuality
    Human 2.0
    Humanism
    Immigration
    Incest
    Indoctrination
    Injustice System
    International Religious News
    Isaiah 17 Prophecy
    Isis
    Islam
    Islam Debunked
    Israel
    Jack-van-impe
    Jack Van Impe Presents
    Jeremiah 49
    Jewish News
    Jews
    Joel Rosenberg
    John Piper
    Korea
    Liberal Nonsense
    Loss Of Liberties
    Mainstream Media Exposed
    Mainstream Media Exposed
    Mark Dice
    Mark Of The Beast
    Martial Law
    Media Deception
    Media Deception
    Mental Health
    Middle East
    Middle-east
    Military
    Millennial Nonsese
    Missionaries
    Multiculturalism
    Multi Culturalism
    Multiculturalism6e9605f9ef
    Murder
    Music Industry
    Music Industry Exposed
    Muslim Agenda
    Mysticism
    Natural Disasters
    New Age
    NewsWatch Video
    New World Order
    Noah
    Nwo
    Occult
    One World Government
    One World Religion
    Oprah
    Parenting
    Pestilence
    Pets
    Planned Parenthood
    Police Brutality
    Police State
    Political Correctness
    Pope
    Pornography
    Positive News
    Poverty
    Prayer Request
    Prepping
    Prophecy
    Prophecy-in-the-news
    Prostitution
    Race Manipulation
    Racism
    Rapture
    Research
    Revival
    Robotics
    Russia
    Salvation
    Saracsm-hoaxes
    Satanism
    Satire
    School Curriculum
    School Violence
    School Violence
    Science
    Sex
    Sex Trafficing
    Sexual Abuse
    Shadow Government
    Sharia Law
    Signs Of End Times
    Social Media
    Spiritual Warfare
    Suicide
    Taking A Stand
    Taking-a-stand
    Technology
    Terrorism
    Terrorism In America
    Testimony
    Transgender
    Transhumanism
    True American History
    United Nations
    Vampirism
    Violence
    Virtue SIgnals
    Walmart
    War On Christianity
    Wars/Rumors Of Wars
    What The?!
    Witchcraft
    Woman Issues
    Word-of-faith
    Xxx-church
    Youth Gone Wild
    Youth Issues
    Youth On Fire

    Archives

    February 2021
    January 2021
    February 2019
    July 2018
    September 2017
    August 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • GOD
    • God's Love Letter To You
    • Does GOD Exist?
    • This Was Your Life
    • Find God
  • Q&A
  • Prophecy
  • COMIC BOOKS
  • Get HELP
    • Speak To A Counselor
    • Bullying Sucks!
    • Depression
    • ADHD
    • Encouragement
    • Fighters
  • Exposed
  • Podcasts
  • Sex
  • Evangelism